This shift in policy comes amid ongoing discussions about the stringent criteria for candidates and follows a recent ruling by the Labour Court that deemed the previous age limit unlawful, citing discrimination on the grounds of age.

Fitness tests standardised across all age groups

Despite the proposed increase in the age limit, all future Garda trainees will still be required to meet the same rigorous medical and fitness conditions as their current counterparts. According to a government spokesperson, standards will be upheld regardless of age, emphasising the importance of maintaining the physical and health requirements for the demanding role of a Garda trainee.

The government had previously stated that the age limit is in place for a reason, reinforcing the necessity of ensuring recruits possess the stamina required for the role. However, Fianna Fáil Justice spokesman Jim O’Callaghan had previously criticised the standards, suggesting they were overly burdensome for candidates. O'Callaghan has been an advocate for broadening the eligibility criteria to attract a more diverse range of applicants.

age discrimination legal challenge

The change in age criteria stems from a Labour Court ruling declaring the previous age limit unlawful, prompting an appeal against the decision. Garda Commissioner Drew Harris had argued during the court proceedings that the age limit of 35 was "essential" to maintain the physical requirements of the job. He contended that stamina was a crucial factor, necessitating the exclusion of older candidates.

Call for inclusivity and career change opportunities

O’Callaghan, a vocal supporter of revising the age limit, emphasised that individuals in their 30s and 40s seeking a career change should not be overlooked. He contended that many people with sedentary careers might be interested in joining the gardaí, bringing practical experience to the force. O’Callaghan expressed optimism that increasing the age limit would expand the pool of candidates applying for the upcoming recruitment competition for An Garda Síochána.

Addressing concerns about the fitness test potentially hindering recruitment, O’Callaghan called for a review of the current test in the face of a recruitment crisis. While acknowledging the importance of a basic level of fitness for a Garda, he proposed a more flexible approach. O’Callaghan suggested designing the test to assess the candidate's current fitness level, with an intensive program tailored accordingly upon admission for those exhibiting a baseline level of fitness.